by Ben Gerig
Despite unanimous public
opposition, by July 2000 the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and Metro
Wastewater had struck a deal for toxic ground water from the former Lowry
landfill to travel through Aurora sewer lines to Metro’s treatment plant in
north Denver.
“This
has never been done anywhere – flushing plutonium-contaminated wastewater
through a public sewer infrastructure,” says former Metro Wastewater board
member and former University of Colorado professor Adrienne Anderson. “I call
it ‘black water’ because it (contains) hazardous and nuclear waste.”
Between
the years 1964 and 1980, the City and County of Denver used the Lowry landfill
located east of Gun Club Road and north of Hampden Ave. as a municipal dumping
ground for industrial wastes. Radioactive chemicals, cleaning solvents, and
pesticides from companies including Coors, Shattuck Chemical Co., and Martin
Marietta were all expunged at the site.
In
her 2001 Westword article,
“Board Games,” Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Eileen Welsome wrote, “The
Lowry landfill contains hundreds of radioactive and non-radioactive chemicals.
Approximately 165 of the 275 chemicals that the Agency for Toxic Substances and
Disease Registry has declared as presenting the ‘most significant potential
threat to human health’ are in the landfill. Only about a third of these
substances – fifteen radionuclides and 53 chemicals – are regulated under the
Metro permit; the remainder simply flow through the sewers.”
Funneled
at the rate of 10 to 20 gallons per minute from Lowry to Metro Waste- water,
the contaminated water joins another 140 million gallons of sewage influent
from the 1.6 million Denver residents that Metro serves. It is then processed
at the plant before a portion is discharged to Denver Water’s recycling plant
for further treatment before being dispersed to Washington Park and other
locations across the city.
Recycled
water is delivered through a separate system of “purple pipes.” Users include
the Denver Zoo, Common Ground golf course, Denver Public Schools, Denver
Country Club, and Washington Park.
“They
don’t have treatment systems to handle hazardous or nuclear waste and the
(Metro) plant is not certified to handle this waste,” Anderson maintains.
“You
can’t treat heavy metal, solvents, and radioactive waste with the kind of
filtering they’re doing,” adds Larry Ambrose, president of Sloan’s Lake
Neighborhood Association. “But they claim they’re treating it.”
Since
2004, Washington and City Park lakes have been filled with reclaimed “purple
pipe” effluent. “The city tests the lake water every year, and in their own
report it says that the water quality does not meet state standards. They
attributed it to the switch to reclaimed water,” says Anderson. “I don’t think
that people realized, ‘God, they’re going to take (reclaimed water) and put it
in our parks, using a purple pipe.’”
“This
is a whole new ball game,” notes Ambrose.
In
the winter of 2007, more than 1,000 ducks inexplicably drowned at the
Waste-water Reclamation District and in City Park’s Ferril Lake. The cause
remains unknown; however, Anderson offers an educated theory. “I think the
1,4-Dioxane (an industrial
cleaning solvent), overwhelmed the water ponds, and the ducks were stripped of
the grease on their feathers and down they went; they drowned.”
“My
understanding is that there has been extensive testing of that water,” claims
Dave Akers of the Colorado Department of Health and Environment. “The
contaminants have been characterized, and Metro has indicated that the water is
acceptable to be treated to necessary standards.”
In
fact, Denver Water’s Lowry webpage states, “The discharge (from Lowry)
represents 0.026 percent of the 140 million gallons per day treated by Metro
Wastewater. Extensive scientific testing by the EPA over more than a decade has
not identified any elevated risk from the Lowry discharge, and there is no
evidence that significant radioactive waste was ever disposed at Lowry
landfill.”
However,
Anderson possesses a copy of an official letter that the attorney for the top
12 Lowry polluters – including Coors and Metro Wastewater – sent to the EPA in
December 1991. It explicitly details that high levels of plutonium and other
radionuclides were found in Lowry’s groundwater after thousands of samples were
tested over four years. The letter attributed Rocky Flats nuclear-weapons plant
as the culprit for the contamination.
“It’s
just a question of, do you believe some of those agencies that have a history
of working with the public, or do you not?” says Joe Sloan, Community Relations
Specialist at Denver Water. “The data that they’ve shown us, and the
understanding that we have, we don’t see it as an issue.”
“This
is something that we test, normally. Basically, we’ve found that the levels (of
radionuclides) that are in the recycled water (are) pretty consistent with what
we see in our drinking water,” adds Denver Water Recycled Water Program Manager
Abigail Holmquist.
Nevertheless,
the influx of the “reclaimed” water filling park lakes remains controversial.
Anderson believes, “The (reclaimed effluent) is responsible for the water
quality decline in Washington Park’s lake and Ferril Lake and (is) the apparent
cause of the death of ducks and fish that have occurred in waves since 2004.
“The
polluters that were responsible for the Lowry landfill, with the complicity of
the EPA and the CDPHE, are (now) using Denver and Aurora public lake
infrastructures as a tertiary treatment system for chemical waste. It’s a
transfer system that cannot be neutralized; it’s (simply) being dispersed,”
Anderson says.
Learn
more about Denver’s dealings with the Lowry landfill and its water by reading
Eileen Welsome’s series at www.Westword.com. Further information
pertaining to the duck deaths may be viewed at www.rmpjc.org or at www.denverdirect.tv.
Denver Water’s information is available at www.denverwater.org, by typing in
“Lowry Landfill Facts.” |